Love the consistency of the paints. The colors don’t really mix that well, for example red and blue make dark grey instead of purple. I got this palette for the purpose of mixing, so, it doesn’t really meet my expectations of what I was planning to use it for. The tin they are in also does not close all the way. The tin is thin and fragile so I think it might have bent a little bit in a way that makes it unable to be closed. So, I give it four stars because although the product is great, the colors do not mix well and the tin is incredibly easy to bend.